METAANALYSIS 
CITATIONS 

BenefitCost Summary Statistics Per Participant  

Benefits to:  
Taxpayers  $292  Benefits minus costs  $426  
Participants  $686  Benefit to cost ratio  $1.70  
Others  $362  Chance the program will produce  
Indirect  ($305)  benefits greater than the costs  50 %  
Total benefits  $1,036  
Net program cost  ($609)  
Benefits minus cost  $426  
Detailed Monetary Benefit Estimates Per Participant  
Benefits from changes to:^{1}  Benefits to:  

Taxpayers  Participants  Others^{2}  Indirect^{3}  Total 

Labor market earnings associated with test scores  $292  $686  $362  $0  $1,340 
Adjustment for deadweight cost of program  $0  $0  $0  ($305)  ($305) 
Totals  $292  $686  $362  ($305)  $1,036 
Detailed Annual Cost Estimates Per Participant  
Annual cost  Year dollars  Summary  

Program costs  $1,413  2018  Present value of net program costs (in 2018 dollars)  ($609) 
Comparison costs  $812  2018  Cost range (+ or )  40 % 
Estimated Cumulative Net Benefits Over Time (NonDiscounted Dollars) 
The graph above illustrates the estimated cumulative net benefits perparticipant for the first fifty years beyond the initial investment in the program. We present these cash flows in nondiscounted dollars to simplify the “breakeven” point from a budgeting perspective. If the dollars are negative (bars below $0 line), the cumulative benefits do not outweigh the cost of the program up to that point in time. The program breaks even when the dollars reach $0. At this point, the total benefits to participants, taxpayers, and others, are equal to the cost of the program. If the dollars are above $0, the benefits of the program exceed the initial investment. 
MetaAnalysis of Program Effects  
Outcomes measured  Treatment age  No. of effect sizes  Treatment N  Adjusted effect sizes(ES) and standard errors(SE) used in the benefit  cost analysis  Unadjusted effect size (random effects model)  

First time ES is estimated  Second time ES is estimated  
ES  SE  Age  ES  SE  Age  ES  pvalue  
Test scores^{}  6  4  277  0.020  0.155  6  0.008  0.170  17  0.039  0.803 
Chambers, B., Abrami, P., Tucker, B., Slavin, R.E., Madden, N.A., Cheung, A., & Gifford, R. (2008). Computerassisted tutoring in Success for All: Reading outcomes for first graders. Journal of Research on Educational Effectiveness, 1(2), 120137.
Fuchs, L.S., Fuchs, D., Hamlet, C.L., Powell, S.R., Capizzi, A.M., & Seethaler, P.M. (2006). The effects of computerassisted instruction on number combination skill in atrisk first graders. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 39(5), 467475.
Kamykowska, J., Haman, E., Richardson, U., Latvala, J.M., & Lyytinen, H. (2014). Developmental changes of early reading skills in sixyearold Polish children and GraphoGame as a computerbased intervention to support them. L1 Educational Studies in Language and Literature, 117.
Mitchell, M.J., & Fox, B.J. (2001). The effects of computer software for developing phonological awareness in lowprogress readers. Reading Research and Instruction, 40, 315332.